HD Powder Showdown: ELF vs Makeup Forever

Disclosure: I purchased the Makeup Forever HD powder myself, and the ELF powder was a PR sample.


Makeup products bearing the High Definition moniker have become more and more common in the last year or so, supposedly because of the need for products which help the skin to look flawless and natural even through high definition cameras.  For normal consumers, this doesn't apply quite so much - our skin isn't filmed and broadcast on the big or small screens, we have significantly less close ups - so HD products are becoming more synonymous with ultra natural, ultra flawless finishes.

Both ELF and Makeup Forever make HD powders, which are transparent, fine powders designed to set foundation and give a soft focus finish.  The major difference between the two is the price point - the ELF powder retails for £6, and the Makeup Forever powder costs £22.50.  The question is, does the Makeup Forever product offer enough more to justify the price difference?

Formula

Both powders are very simple in formula, with similar ingredients.  The Makeup Forever powder is 100% silica powder, and the ELF powder lists its ingredients as Dimethicone/Vinyl Dimethicone Crosspolymer and silica.  So, not much difference between the two there.

Packaging

In my opinion, this is where the big differences lie.  The Makeup Forever powder is contained within a small glass pot.  The powder sits beneath a sifter with a couple of holes in it, and the small diameter of the pot makes it slightly difficult to swirl a powder brush in it.  It's pretty easy to dispense powder though; turning the pot upside down with the lid on allows a small amount of powder to flow through the sifter, which is plenty to cover the whole face.  This makes it slightly more portable than the ELF, as the amount of powder dispensed is smaller.

The ELF powder comes in a larger, squared off plastic pot, which is less weighty than the MUFE offering.  It's also got a much wider opening, which makes it easy to dip or swirl a powder brush as necessary.  There are also more holes in the sifter, which conversely makes it quite hard to get powder out of the pot without making a big mess; turning the pot upside down causes a very large amount of powder to fall through.  Not only does this make it harder to control how much powder ends up on the brush, but it also causes powder to fall onto the shoulders of the pot - which is very messy indeed.

Neither powder is particularly portable once the sticker is removed from the sifter - a prolonged period upside down will result in lots of powder being dispensed.  However, the MUFE is just a little bit too small in diameter, so the ELF powder wins this round.

Performance

As you might guess, with such similar formulations, both powders perform to the same standard.  I've used both for a good few months now, and am equally pleased with both products.  Applied over foundation, the powders provide a pretty semi-matte finish, and do indeed make the skin look flawlessly smooth.  They both last very well, with shiny nose only occurring after about 8 hours, which is pretty good in my estimation.  The best thing, for me, is the silkiness of the powders, which really translates across onto the skin - the finish is very smooth, and very silky.  So long as you don't overapply, you don't get any ashy or whitish tone either.  No winner for this category.

Verdict


To all intents and purposes, I think these powders are pretty much the same.  The ELF has the edge in terms of the packaging, provided you don't want to carry it around with you, and is definitely better value for money than the more expensive MUFE version.  I will definitely be repurchasing the ELF product in the future - silica powders have now become my favourite foundation setting loose powder, and the ELF product represents the best value for money.

If you'd like to try either product, you can get the Makeup Forever HD powder from the Guru Makeup Emporium in the UK for £22.50, and the ELF HD powder from ELF's website for £6.